Map — "What must be true?"¶
Mindset: Experienced newcomer. Understand the accepted result before judging it. Test: "Can I name the material claims, harms, boundaries, evidence identities and limits?" RF: RF path TS: TS path
Understanding¶
{2–3 sentences: accepted result, purpose, key decisions and scope}
Accepted Claims and Boundaries¶
Map the result before selecting checks. Safety/security, human acceptance authority and accepted-result identity are mandatory even when no ordinary claim sample selects them.
| ID | Layer | Accepted claim / authority boundary | Risk or concrete harm | Affected behavior / dependencies | Relevant environment | Oracle / authority | Evidence identity (subject@revision, source) |
Required? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | VALUE / ASSURANCE / TRACE | {claim or boundary} | {harm if false} | {behavior and dependencies} | {environment} | {oracle or ruler} | {exact identity} | yes / selected |
TS ↔ RF Alignment¶
| TS requirement | RF claim | Claim IDs | Aligned? |
|---|---|---|---|
| {AC / DoF item} | {RF section} | {C1…} | ✅ / ❌ / ⚠️ partial |
Verification Selection¶
| Claim IDs | Planned check or reusable evidence | Why this depth | Known gap or limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| {C1…} | {action / artifact} | {risk, dependency, environment, oracle} | {none or explicit limit} |
Deviations from TS¶
{List RF work outside TS, TS items not addressed, or "No deviations." A deviation is not a finding until Verify establishes fact, harm and material consequence.}
Checkpoint¶
Self-check: - [ ] Read RF §§1–5, governing TS AC/DoF, HL purpose/principles, ONB and referenced predecessors? - [ ] Mapped every material accepted claim and the mandatory safety/security, authority and result-identity boundaries? - [ ] Bound each claim to affected behavior/dependencies, environment, oracle/authority and exact evidence identity? - [ ] Recorded a replayable verification selection and every known gap or limit? - [ ] Avoided classifying by filename, discrepancy count or artifact volume?
Stage complete: YES / NO