title: "Map — "What was done?"" source: "tasks/TFW-55__canonization_program/phase-b/review/phase-b2/map.md"
Map — "What was done?"¶
Mindset: Experienced newcomer. You arrived after someone else's work. Understand before you judge. No opinions yet — only comprehension. Test: "Can I explain what was done to someone who hasn't read the RF?" Review target:
f8b0731b1624f7ab28f80020519702cb85e6014bRF: RF Phase B.2 TS: TS Phase B.2
Understanding¶
The Executor replaced the previously rejected compact public doorway with a practical project guide derived from the exact public prefix of b924926:README.md, while retaining the live English Task Board from the Phase B.2 execution baseline. It then replaced the Russian and Kazakh doorway summaries with full localized project guides, collected isolated draft and exact-final language critiques, and recorded the restoration, localization, integrity checks, and superseded B1 history in new Phase B.2 ONB, EV, language-review, and RF artifacts.
The implementation claims eight execution-stage paths: three modified root READMEs and five new Phase B.2 trace files. It deliberately leaves the approved Project North Star essay, master/phase contracts, framework mechanics, Editions, old B1 traces, research, knowledge, BoK sources, and unrelated files unchanged.
TS ↔ RF Alignment¶
| TS requirement | RF claim | Aligned? |
|---|---|---|
AC-1 — exact b924926 baseline, complete disposition ledger, classified changes, current board source |
RF §3 reports 1,485 words, the required SHA-256, complete EV ledgers, and start commit 2a534c70… for the board tail |
✅ claimed |
| AC-2 — English remains a practical project guide with all seven newcomer functions | RF §§1–4 report every practical section restored and a seven-question walkthrough | ✅ claimed |
| AC-3 — minimal Philosophy-of-Trace alignment without a second essay | RF §§2–4 report one bounded definition, human authority, selected Trace, removed overclaims, and an outward essay link | ✅ claimed |
| AC-4 — current Editions, starts, commands, mechanics, paths, anchors, and links | RF §4 reports current source checks, 11 exact commands, 35 targets per language, and preserved external strings | ✅ claimed |
| AC-5 — complete natural Russian localization | RF §§3–5 cite full parity, strict UTF-8, exact identifiers, no board, and exact-final critic acceptance | ✅ claimed |
| AC-6 — complete natural Kazakh localization | RF §§3–5 cite full parity, strict UTF-8, exact identifiers, no board, and exact-final critic acceptance | ✅ claimed |
| AC-7 — independent critic closure and exact-final lineage | RF §§2–4 report separate RU/KK critics, all 22 draft findings dispositioned, exact-final rechecks, and unresolved HIGH 0/0 |
✅ claimed |
| AC-8 — language switch, board/source integrity, encoding, and approved production scope | RF §§3–4 report one EN board, zero RU/KK boards, non-TFW-55 tail and TFW-60 identity, unchanged essay blob, and three production paths | ✅ claimed |
| AC-9 — corrective provenance, complete trace, no placeholders or BoK, stale D66 deferred | RF §§1–6 and §10 identify both baselines, owner rejection, superseded B1, evidence artifacts, D66 deferral, and residual limits | ✅ claimed |
Deviations from TS¶
The RF reports no scope or implementation deviations. The execution diff is claimed as exactly the eight TS-authorized paths, with 1,415 changed lines against the TS estimate of no more than 1,800. The RF also records one accepted non-blocking Kazakh LOW observation (KK-F-L1) and one pre-existing missing TFW-55 Iteration 2 target; neither is presented as a deviation or repaired in execution.
The first Phase B RF/REVIEW remains a separate superseded chain. Its earlier APPROVE is not used as acceptance evidence for Phase B.2; the controlling product requirement is the owner-approved Amendment A6 at master freeze 5dee93d.
Checkpoint¶
Self-check: - [x] Read RF §1–§5 completely? - [x] Read TS DoD and matched each item to RF §3? - [x] Read HL §7 Principles — can I state the design philosophy? - [x] Read ONB — were blocking questions resolved?
Stage complete: YES