REVIEW — TFW-46 / Phase C: Glossary + Adapters + Version¶
Date: 2026-07-07 Author: Reviewer (Antigravity, Claude Opus 4.6) Verdict: ✅ APPROVE Review Mode: docs RF: RF Phase C TS: TS Phase C Stage files:
review/map.md,review/verify.md,review/judge.mdThis file is a synthesis of stage findings. Reference stage files for raw evidence.
1. Map¶
Executor completed the final phase of TFW-46 (Evidence Layer): added 5 Evidence-related glossary entries under ## Evidence Terms, fixed TD-118 stale reference (RF §7 → RF §8), synced 6 adapter workflow copies via byte-identical file copy, bumped VERSION to 0.8.8, and wrote a comprehensive CHANGELOG entry covering all three TFW-46 phases. In a KNW cleanup pass, executor also fixed 3 tech debt items: TD-111 (compilable_contract.md kebab-case), TD-112 (handoff.md kebab-case), TD-117 (compilable_contract.md stale §5→§7 ref). Adapters re-synced after handoff.md fix. Key decision: Evidence Status Vocabulary as a standalone glossary entry for independent referenceability.
2. Verify¶
| # | What was checked | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | glossary.md: 5 Evidence terms present, domain-agnostic, cross-refs | ✅ | Lines 59-80: Evidence, Evidence Plan, Evidence Collection, Evidence Audit, Evidence Status Vocabulary |
| V2 | glossary.md: TD-118 fix (RF §7 → §8) | ✅ | Line 48: reads RF §8 |
| V3 | VERSION = 0.8.8 | ✅ | Single-line file confirmed |
| V4 | CHANGELOG [0.8.8] entry structure | ✅ | Lines 8-22: Added (9 items) + Changed (3 items), TFW-46 refs, [Unreleased] above |
| V5 | 6 adapter pairs byte-identical | ✅ | SHA256 hashes verified: handoff/review/plan × .agent + .claude — all match canonical |
| V6 | TD-111: compilable_contract.md PhaseA/ → phase-a/ |
✅ | L56 and L78 confirmed kebab-case |
| V7 | TD-112: handoff.md Multi-Phase example kebab-case | ✅ | L148-156: TS__phase-a, RF__phase-a, no stale HL__PhaseA |
| V8 | TD-117: compilable_contract.md §5 FC → §7 FC |
✅ | L69 confirmed §7 FC |
| V9 | Handoff adapters re-synced after TD-112 fix | ✅ | SHA256: canonical = .agent = .claude (new hash after fix) |
Raw verification log: see
review/verify.md(original) + reviewer re-verification of TD fixes. 8 of 13 files verified (62% — exceeds 42% minimum). No discrepancies found.
3. Judge¶
| # | Check | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria) | ✅ | All 4 ACs verified: glossary terms (V1), adapters (V5/V9), VERSION (V3), CHANGELOG (V4). Plus 3 TD closures verified (V6-V8) |
| 2 | Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy) | ✅ | P4 domain-agnostic: no domain-specific examples in glossary. P2 honest incompleteness: DEFERRED/BLOCKED defined |
| 3 | Tech debt documented | ✅ | RF §6: "No observations" — all found stale refs fixed (TD-111, TD-112, TD-117, TD-118). Clean |
| 4 | Style & standards | ✅ | Glossary pattern followed, CHANGELOG format correct, naming conventions respected, kebab-case consistent |
| 5 | Observations collected | ✅ | Explicitly stated "No observations" — valid since all issues found were fixed |
| 6 | RF completeness (§7-9 present) | ✅ | All present with explicit "No X" (valid for docs/sync phase) |
| 7 | Evidence completeness | ✅ | TS marked all 4 ACs as Evidence: N/A. Executor provided 12 VERIFIED evidence items (7 original + 5 TD fixes) |
| 8 | Content quality (docs mode) | ✅ | Glossary terms clear, accurate, cross-referenced. CHANGELOG coherent. TD fixes precise |
| 9 | Source verification (docs mode) | ✅ | All glossary cross-references verified. compilable_contract.md references now correct |
4. Verdict¶
✅ APPROVE
Clean documentation, sync, and tech debt cleanup phase. All 4 acceptance criteria met and independently verified. 3 additional tech debt items (TD-111, TD-112, TD-117) fixed and verified — all kebab-case and stale section references now correct. Adapters re-synced after handoff.md fix. No discrepancies found during verification.
This phase completes TFW-46 (Evidence Layer). Version 0.8.8 is canonical.
5. Tech Debt Collected¶
| # | Source | Severity | File | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | — | — | No new tech debt. TD-111, TD-112, TD-117, TD-118 all closed during this phase | — |
6. Traces Updated¶
- [x] README Task Board — status updated (Phase C REVIEW link added)
- [x] HL status — no change (HL already ✅ HL_APPROVED)
- [ ] project_config.yaml — initial_seq: no change needed
- [x] Other project files — TECH_DEBT.md: TD-118 status → ✅ Closed
- [x] tfw-docs: Applied — updated §1 (D52 Architecture Decision), §2 (TFW-46 Key Artifact)
- [x] tfw-knowledge: Applied — 10 facts consolidated across 5 topic files (philosophy +4, process +3, constraint +1, stakeholder +1, domain +1)
7. Fact Candidates¶
No fact candidates.
REVIEW — TFW-46 / Phase C: Glossary + Adapters + Version | 2026-07-07