REVIEW — TFW-8 / Phase B: Documentation Sync

Date: 2026-03-12 Author: Reviewer (AI) Verdict: ✅ APPROVE RF: RF Phase B TS: TS TFW-8

---

1. Review Checklist

#	Check	Status	Notes
1	DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria)	✅	All 5 Phase B criteria verified — see details below
2	Code quality (conventions, naming, type hints)	N/A	No code — Markdown documentation
3	Test coverage (tests written and passing)	✅	9 test checks in RF, all independently verified
4	Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy)	✅	All references now consistently mention review as separate workflow and Reviewer as distinct role
5	Tech debt (shortcuts documented?)	✅	3 observations documented, triaged below
6	Security (no secrets exposed, guards in place)	N/A	Documentation changes only
7	Observability	N/A	No runtime components
8	Breaking changes (backward compat, migrations)	✅	Non-breaking — only added references, no removals
9	Observations collected (executor reported findings)	✅	3 valid observations

Verification Details

#	Acceptance Criterion	Result	Evidence
1	.tfw/README.md directory tree, workflows table, evolution updated	✅	L77 "review" in workflow list; L169 review/Reviewer row in table; L205 4 roles; L212 Reviewer; L283 review in evolution
2	plan.md mentions /tfw-review after handoff	✅	L76 small task path; L87-88 multi-phase diagram; L112, L117 references
3	resume.md mentions review step	✅	L84 step 15 — review workflow reference after handoff
4	init.md review in copy instructions and workflow lists	✅	L98 copy command; L185 workflow reference; L193 template structure
5	Antigravity adapter README has review in setup, listing, sync	✅	L22 setup copy; L41 directory listing; L54 sync section

2. Verdict

✅ APPROVE

Phase B complete. All documentation references across the project now consistently reflect the review workflow and Reviewer role. Combined with Phase A's structural changes, TFW-8 is fully delivered:

• Executor can no longer stumble into self-review (Phase A)
• All docs consistently reference /tfw-review as the review entry point (Phase B)
• No stale references to "Executor + Coordinator" remain in handoff descriptions

Task TFW-8 is ready for closure.

3. Tech Debt Collected

#	Source	Severity	File	Description	Action
TD-14	RF obs. #1	Low	.tfw/README.md L214	"one AI agent fills both Coordinator and Executor roles" — doesn't mention Reviewer for small projects	Accepted — small projects may self-review; sentence is accurate
TD-15	RF obs. #2	Low	.tfw/README.md L252	Anti-patterns says "Coordinator skips review" — could say "Reviewer"	Accepted — "Coordinator skips review" still valid (coordinator initiates the review step)
TD-16	RF obs. #3	Low	.tfw/CHANGELOG.md L31	Historical v0.2.0 entry says "3 canonical workflows"	Accepted — historical record, accurate for that version

4. Traces Updated

• [x] README Task Board — updated to ✅ DONE
• [x] TECH_DEBT.md — TD-14, TD-15, TD-16 appended
• [x] PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml — initial_seq incremented to 9
• [x] tfw-docs: Applied 2026-03-14 — KNOWLEDGE.md already contained all TFW-8 entries (P7, D13, Key Artifacts §2, Legacy §3 — applied during task); /tfw-docs confirmed complete

---

REVIEW — TFW-8 / Phase B: Documentation Sync | 2026-03-12