REVIEW — TFW-6 / Phase A: Core Versioning Infrastructure¶
Date: 2026-03-12 Author: Coordinator (AI) Verdict: 🔄 REVISE RF: RF Phase A TS: TS Phase A
1. Review Checklist¶
| # | Check | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria) | ⚠️ | 6/7 met. One inconsistency in CHANGELOG wording — see §2 |
| 2 | Code quality (conventions, naming, type hints) | ✅ | Pure Markdown/YAML, all well-structured |
| 3 | Test coverage (tests written and passing) | N/A | No code — Markdown/YAML artifacts only |
| 4 | Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy) | ✅ | Plain text, no tooling, optional over mandatory, retroactive completeness |
| 5 | Tech debt (shortcuts documented?) | ✅ | Two observations properly documented in RF §5 |
| 6 | Security (no secrets exposed, guards in place) | N/A | No secrets involved |
| 7 | Breaking changes (backward compat, migrations) | ✅ | New version field in PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml is additive, not breaking |
| 8 | Style & standards (code style, conventions) | ✅ | Follows Keep a Changelog, valid semver, consistent Markdown |
| 9 | Observations collected (executor reported findings) | ✅ | 2 observations: README table formatting, placeholder build commands |
2. Verdict¶
🔄 REVISE
Items to fix:¶
- CHANGELOG.md line 16: Says
added tfw_version fieldbut the actual field name isversion(under thetfw:namespace). The TS Step 3 explicitly clarified this, and the executor got it right in PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml — but the CHANGELOG text is inconsistent.
Current: - PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml — added tfw_version field
Should be: - PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml — added tfw.version field
This is a one-word fix but matters because CHANGELOG is consumed by downstream projects via tfw-update — inaccurate field names would cause confusion during upgrades.
3. Tech Debt Collected¶
| # | Source | Severity | File | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TD-5 | RF obs. #1 | Low | README.md L53-54 |
Empty line splitting Root Files table rows (KNOWLEDGE.md / TECH_DEBT.md) | → backlog |
| TD-6 | RF obs. #2 | Med | .tfw/PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml L17-20 |
Build commands are placeholder echo — not configured for this project (meta-project has no build) |
→ accepted (meta-project doesn't build; placeholder is correct for template purposes) |
4. Traces Updated¶
- [ ] README Task Board — status updated → after REVISE fix
- [ ] TECH_DEBT.md — TD-5 appended (TD-6 accepted, no action)
- [ ] tfw-docs: N/A — Phase A only, full knowledge update after Phase C
REVIEW — TFW-6 / Phase A: Core Versioning Infrastructure | 2026-03-12