---

title: "Verify — "Are the claims true?"" source: "tasks/TFW-60__conflict_resistant_shared_workspace/phase-ab/review/verify.md"

---

Verify — "Are the claims true?"

Mindset: Auditor. The RF is a declaration, not a fact. Open files. Run commands. Compare claims against reality. Test: "If I removed the RF, would the evidence alone prove the work was done?" Min verify ratio: 0.42 (tfw.review.min_verify_ratio) RF files claimed: 23 implementation paths + 8 work artifacts = 31 Files to verify: ⌈31 × 0.42⌉ = 14 — escalated to 31 (100%) on discrepancy D1 Method: git diff 57a5147 ecfceee -- <path> for every implementation file; every evidence file read in full; commands re-run in this session on the working tree at ecfceee (unrelated TFW-55 research files dirty, untouched)

Verification Log

V1: .tfw/scripts/gen_index.py

• RF claim: current grammar, whole-input dispatch, directory collision refusal, truthful malformed reporting, ReaderError key recovery, free-form via validation, retired-key checks
• Actual: CURRENT_ID added, fullmatch-ed first in parse_identifier(); TASK_DIR removed; IdentifierCollisionError raised from _walk_containers() naming identifier and both paths; explain_yaml_error() recovers the key from exc.position when no mark; validate_event() rejects empty/non-string via; id_max_retries and review.default_mode added to retired keys; unresolved reason now says "reported as malformed", no longer "rename it by hand"
• Match: ✅

V2: .tfw/scripts/migrate_board.py

• RF claim: shared whole parsing replaces prefix extraction; duplicate refusal; exact partitions; computed pre-write guarantees; faithful prose; manifest disclosure
• Actual: re.search(r"[A-Z][A-Z0-9]*-\d+") gone; _identifier_text() unwraps link label / emphasis / strike then parse_identifier(); reconcile() raises MigrationRefusal on duplicate rows naming both lines; computed_guarantees() returns three partition equalities with arithmetic and missing/duplicate detail; require_guarantees() called in plan() and first thing in render_manifest(); _plain() strips _ only at word boundaries; manifest has ## Malformed identifiers, ## Guarantees checked (arithmetic + HELD) and ## Guarantees not checked by this run; written derives identifiers through the dispatcher instead of split("__")[0]; main() catches both refusals and prints REFUSING … Nothing was changed, exit 1
• Match: ⚠️ partial — see D1: line 750 prints **Unaccounted: 0.** as a string constant

V3: .tfw/scripts/test_gen_index.py · V4: .tfw/scripts/test_migrate_board.py

• RF claim: current/dirty/legacy, malformed, collision, guarantee, prose, via, ReaderError and retired-key regressions incl. committed HELPDESK_SHAPE
• Actual: all present. HELPDESK_SHAPE carries exactly the five candidates the TS gate names. Duplicate-row test asserts manifest not created and both line numbers named. Unbalanced test removes [TFW-9](../../../TFW-9__update_source_mechanism/HL-TFW-9__update_source_mechanism.md) and asserts the guarantee name and identifier in the refusal
• Match: ✅ — with one note feeding D1: test_migrate_board.py:237 and :508 assert the literal "Unaccounted: 0"

V5: .tfw/conventions.md · V6: .tfw/glossary.md · V7: .tfw/project_config.yaml

• RF claim: PREFIX_stamp_ABBR issued, both historical forms preserved, collision refusal defined, via free-form
• Actual: §4 Identifier rewritten as claimed; id_max_retries removed from config; via row and a new paragraph declare descriptive provenance. Glossary Task Naming names all three forms
• Match: ✅. Note for judge row 9: the §4 Artifact file naming table (HL-{ID}.md …) was not extended with a current-grammar example, and its prose addresses only clock and legacy tasks

V8: .tfw/workflows/plan.md · V9: .tfw/workflows/init.md

• RF claim: owner approves ABBR before creation, one clock read, exact-path refusal, session naming with full ID
• Actual: plan.md Step 3.5 asks for the abbreviation in the batched exchange; Step 4.2 pseudocode reads clock once, if dir exists: STOP; ask the owner to approve a different abbreviation; retry loop and id_max_retries gone; init.md interview batch 1 asks for the abbreviation and step 6 creates {PREFIX}_{stamp}_{ABBR} with the same refusal
• Match: ✅

V10: .tfw/workflows/update.md

• RF claim: 852 words; source/tag pins and recheck; installed-baseline provenance; reachable retired-term check; installed-adapter-only sync
• Actual: wc -w = 852. "Before Step 0" pins source_head, verifies refs/tags/v${target}^{commit} equals it; Step 5 rechecks both; Step 3 compares against installed_from; Step 6 requires zero hits outside an allowlist; Step 6 creates no target directory for uninstalled adapters
• Match: ⚠️ partial — see D2: Step 0 and Step 9 state that .tfw/.upstream-source/ is gitignored; .gitignore lists only .tfw/.upstream/

V11: .tfw/migrations/2.0.0.md

• RF claim: three grammars named, staging claim removed, malformed inputs non-actionable, split test commands
• Actual: all four present; "Commit whatever board changes are in flight … adding files to the Git index changes nothing the migration can see"; -k "not repository" before step 2, -k repository after the index exists
• Match: ✅

V12: .tfw/templates/project_config.yaml · V13: .tfw/templates/HL.md · V14: .tfw/templates/status.md

• RF claim: issuance examples updated, HL abbreviation field, scope budgets marked project-owned
• Actual: id_format: "{PREFIX}_{YYYYMMDD}-{HHMMSS}_{ABBR}", scope_budgets: ← PROJECT; HL header gains > **Abbreviation**: {ABBR}; status template id: PREFIX_YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS_ABBR, authority: HL-PREFIX_YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS_ABBR.md
• Match: ✅

V15: .tfw/compilable_contract.md · V16: docs/scripts/gen_docs.py · V17: docs/scripts/test_gen_docs.py

• RF claim: references across all three grammars, underscore-safe boundaries, exact normalized directory matching
• Actual: task_id_source alternation of the three forms; \b replaced by (?<![A-Za-z0-9_]) … (?![A-Za-z0-9_/\]]); _task_glob() matches directories through gen_index.parse_identifier() equality instead of a {task_id}* glob; three new tests incl. boundary rejection of X{id}, {id}_TAIL, _BAD_ABBR, _lower
• Match: ✅

V18–V23: .claude/commands/tfw-{plan,update,init}.md · .agent/workflows/tfw-{plan,update,init}.md

• RF claim: six approved byte-identical copies
• Actual: sha1sum — each triplet identical (35a116a2…, ad0be818…, b8f06a7f…). All 11 .agents/skills/tfw-*/SKILL.md hash-equal to .tfw/adapters/codex/skills/
• Match: ✅

V24: phase-ab/status.md · V25: phase-ab/journal/20260829-165540__transition__d26e.md

• RF claim: RF lifecycle and completion timestamp recorded; durable transition into execution
• Actual: lifecycle: RF, updated: 20260829-173155; event carries on_behalf_of: saubakirov, via: codex, two refs, summary within ceiling
• Match: ✅ — note: no event records execution → RF (the updated stamp at 17:31 has no journal entry). Low; carried to judge row 4

V26–V31: RF, EV, five evidence .txt

• Read in full; contents checked under Evidence Verification below.

Commands Executed

#	Command	Result
1	python -m pytest .tfw/scripts/ docs/scripts/ -q -k "not repository"	281 passed, 3 deselected (179 s) — matches RF
2	python -m pytest .tfw/scripts/ docs/scripts/ -q -k repository	2 passed, 1 skipped, 281 deselected — matches RF; 281 + 2 = 283 passed, 1 skipped = RF full-suite figure
3	python .tfw/scripts/gen_index.py --check tasks	53 tasks validate; exit 0
4	python .tfw/scripts/gen_index.py --check project	consistent with 2.0.0-dirty.3; names what it did not check; exit 0
5	wc -w .tfw/workflows/update.md	852
6	sha1sum on 3 workflow triplets; hash compare of 11 Codex skill pairs	all identical
7	git diff --numstat 57a5147 ecfceee excluding copies and work artifacts	17 files, +712 −317 = 1029 — matches RF
8	Inline Python: parse_board(HELPDESK_SHAPE), _plain(...), parse_identifier(...)	HD-30 legacy · HD-30b malformed · TFW-01_single_underscore malformed · 20260829-010832__dirty clock · TFW_20260829-010832_ABT current; _plain keeps normalize_text() and working_days, removes _emph_, **b**, ~~s~~ — reproduces parser_and_prose_before_after.txt
9	git log --format="%h %s" \| grep -E '^\S+ \[[^]]*/TFW-60/freeze/'	five freeze commits; latest 810b1b8 = TS header baseline
10	cat .gitignore	contains .tfw/.upstream/; does not contain .tfw/.upstream-source/ → D2

Claim & Source Checks

#	Claim / citation checked	Where it appears	Traces to	Holds?
C1	"The collapse is the unanchored re.search() in migrate_board.parse_board(), before LEGACY_ID is consulted"	RF §2.1, ONB §1, TS AC-1 R2	git show 57a5147:.tfw/scripts/migrate_board.py line 130: identifier = re.search(r"[A-Z][A-Z0-9]*-\d+", cells[0]) — confirmed; LEGACY_ID is anchored ^…$ and never saw the cell	✅
C2	"Every identifier parsed before Phase AB still parses to the same kind and normalized identifier at four pinned commits" — 53 / 2 / 15 / 30	four_corpora_compatibility.txt	The framework count is checkable here: --check tasks reports 53 tasks on this tree; the 53 listed identifiers are TFW-1…TFW-61 minus gaps, consistent with tasks/. The three external pins (97dd429, 58329e7, aec5f2d) are at paths outside this repository and were not re-opened in this review; the method (pre-change regexes reimplemented inline vs. new dispatcher over git ls-tree) is stated and sound	✅ for this corpus; external corpora accepted on stated method
C3	"283 passed, 1 skipped" / "281 + 3 deselected" / "2 passed, 1 skipped"	RF §4	Commands 1–2	✅
C4	"Scope: 23 physical, 17 counted, 0 new, 1029 counted-line churn"	RF §4, verification_gates.txt	Command 7 and git show --stat ecfceee (23 non-artifact paths)	✅
C5	"TD-197's implementation decision is closed in this RF"	RF §2.5, §3 AC-7	conventions.md §4 via row + paragraph; validate_event() non-empty check; tests. But .tfw/templates/journal/event.md:49 and :70 still define via as "provider family: claude, codex, gemini" — RF O4 admits this	⚠️ closed at the TS gate (canon + validator); one definition site still disagrees
C6	"All seven third-report §7 items are fixed or filed"	RF §3 AC-8, verification_gates.txt	Field report §7 lists exactly seven bullets: ReaderError key · profile.md contradiction · scope_budgets marker · review.default_mode · antigravity {version} · "commit, or at least stage" · unused adapters copied. Dispositions: 1 FIXED (test at test_gen_index.py ReaderError), 2 FILED (O2), 3 FIXED (template ← PROJECT), 4 FIXED (check_project nested key), 5 FILED (O3), 6 FIXED (guide), 7 FIXED (update.md Step 6)	✅
C7	"Both temporary directories are gitignored"	update.md Step 0 and Step 9 (new text)	.gitignore — only .tfw/.upstream/	❌ → D2

Discrepancies Found

D1 — a guarantee printed as a constant. migrate_board.py:750 emits **Unaccounted: 0.** Every board row is classified exactly once; … as a string literal, and test_migrate_board.py:237 and :508 assert that literal. The sentence is entailed — require_guarantees() at the top of render_manifest() raises before this line can run on an unbalanced corpus — but the line itself computes nothing and shows no arithmetic, and it is the very sentence the third report quoted over a table that listed HD-30 twice. The computed form already exists eleven lines lower under ## Guarantees checked. TS AC-2 bullet 1 gives exactly two acceptable states for an asserted invariant: computed under a heading naming the guarantee, or deleted — "not both left standing". This is both left standing. TS §7 DoF: "A guarantee printed that the tool did not compute." Small: delete the line and the two assertions, or print the count from computed_guarantees()[0].

D2 — a false sentence in a shipped workflow. update.md Step 0: "Both temporary directories are gitignored." Step 9: "Both are gitignored; leaving them is harmless." .tfw/.upstream-source/ is not in this repository's .gitignore, and neither directory is ignored in any receiving project unless its owner adds them — the payload ships no .gitignore. The pre-change text made the narrower claim about .tfw/.upstream/ only, which is true here. The rewrite widened a repository-local fact into a false one and shipped it in a phase whose subject is honest tool text. Fix: either add .tfw/.upstream-source/ to .gitignore and reword to "add both to .gitignore if they are not already", or drop the claim.

Not a discrepancy, recorded for the judge: the AC-3 fixture named its HL HL-TFW_20260829-172110_ABT__approved_fixture.md — a title appended after the identifier — while the same commit's templates/status.md teaches authority: HL-PREFIX_YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS_ABBR.md and conventions.md §4 says {ID} "means the same thing everywhere … no title is appended" (stated for clock tasks; silent for the current grammar). The fixture is discarded and the AC-3 gate does not name artifact filenames, so this is not an AC failure; it is the artifact-naming section left unextended, and the executor's own fixture tripped on the gap. → judge row 9, tech debt.

Escalated to 100% verification: all 23 implementation paths and all 8 work artifacts opened.

Evidence Verification

#	RF Evidence ref	Artifact exists?	Matches claim?
E1	evidence/parser_and_prose_before_after.txt · evidence/four_corpora_compatibility.txt	✅	✅ — before/after output reproduced by command 8; four-corpus method stated, this corpus's 53 confirmed
E2	evidence/runtime_guarantees.txt	✅	✅ — three HELD lines with arithmetic; deliberate failure names guarantee and [TFW-9](../../../TFW-9__update_source_mechanism/HL-TFW-9__update_source_mechanism.md); matches test_deliberately_unbalanced_result_names_failed_guarantee_and_identifier
E3	evidence/current_id_end_to_end.txt	✅	⚠️ — creation, clock read, HL abbreviation, status title and index row are observed (index row quoted). The collision clause is a transcription of the rule, not an observed refusal: no second creation was attempted. The creation path is agent-executed prose, so nothing else could have run; the EV should have said "verified as text" for that clause. Also the HL filename appends a title (see Discrepancies, last paragraph)
E4	evidence/parser_and_prose_before_after.txt	✅	✅ — plain= normalize_text() and working_days plus emphasis
E5	evidence/verification_gates.txt	✅	✅ — both -k selections reproduced (commands 1–2); guide names both commands in order (V11)
E6	evidence/verification_gates.txt	✅	✅ — 852 words reproduced; missing-tag fixture shows exit 128, fatal: Needed a single revision; the workflow text carries every rule claimed (V10). D2 sits in the same file but outside E6's claim
E7	evidence/verification_gates.txt	✅	✅ — test_via_accepts_unregistered_tool_text_and_is_optional_for_hand_edits passes local-tool/v7
E8	evidence/verification_gates.txt	✅	✅ — seven dispositions each traced (C6)
E9	TS AC-8 · ONB answer 2	✅	✅ — DEFERRED names its blocker (/tfw-release after review, §15); a legitimate DEFERRED

Total evidence items: 9 · verified: 8 · partial: 1 (E3, collision clause) · missing: 0.

Knowledge Citations Verified

PV scan performed: priority 0 (README.md opening, § How It Works — heading exists at line 135; .tfw/README.md NS1–NS3 at anchors ns1/ns2/ns3), priority 1 (methodology-values, success-criteria, where-truth-belongs anchors exist), priority 2 (knowledge/philosophy.md), priority 3 (KNOWLEDGE.md §1), priority 4 (conventions.md §3, §11, §14) in full; 5–7 by relevance (convention.md, process.md, risk.md, constraint.md rows cited).

#	Artifact	Priority + exact citation	Link resolves?	Item exists?	Meaning matches?	Relevant to asserted application?
1	HL §7.2 #1 / ONB #1	PV 0 — README.md opening and § How It Works	✅	✅	✅ — "another authorized person or agent can understand … inspect its material grounds"	✅ — a manifest that computes what it prints is inspectable grounds; an uncomputed one is not
2	HL #2 / ONB #2	PV 0 — .tfw/README.md NS1, NS2 principles 3 and 5	✅	✅	✅ — "Selected Trace, not transcript"; "Continuation over isolated output"	✅ — refusing malformed input and reporting it is selected trace; guessing is fabricated continuity
3	HL #3 / ONB #3	PV 1 — Methodology values: Structural Enforcement	✅	✅	✅ — "a rule that cannot reveal its own violation is only advice"	✅ — pre-write gates over manifest prose; also the ground of TD-197
4	HL #4 / ONB #4	PV 1 — Methodology values + § Where truth belongs	✅	✅	✅ — one authoritative owner per truth type	✅ — migration reports and exits; D37 keeps KNOWLEDGE.md with /tfw-docs
5	HL #5 / ONB #5	PV 1 — Portability + § Success Criteria	✅	✅	✅	✅ — grammar carriers must agree in a receiving project (the ten-path R2 addition is this item applied)
6–10	HL #6–#10 / ONB #6–#10	PV 2 — philosophy.md F4, F11, F27, F34, F38	✅	✅ all five rows present	✅ — structural gates; no extra entities; observable progress; vague → usable; coordinator attention finite	✅ — F11 is the ground for one dispatcher rather than a per-consumer regex; F27 for arithmetic printed with each guarantee
11–15	HL #11–#15 / ONB #11–#15	PV 3 — D31, D50, D37, D43, D55, D59, D65	✅	✅ all rows present	✅	✅ — D43 is the functional reason gen_docs.py entered scope; D59 (declaration ≠ authentication) is the reason via is free-form; D65 — no trace renamed
16–17	HL #16–#17 / ONB #16–#17	PV 4 — conventions.md §§3–5, §13–14	✅	✅	✅	✅ — §15 role lock decided AC-8's owner; §14 anti-pattern "status normalized into vocabulary" governs malformed handling
18	HL #18 / ONB #18	PV 5 — convention.md F22	✅	✅	✅ — board is a process artifact	✅ — the retired board is migration input, not product authority
19	HL #19 / ONB #19	PV 6 — process.md F7, F30	✅	✅	✅ — cross-session loss; capture without enforcement site	✅ — rules moved into update.md steps and manifest arithmetic, not into a session
20	HL #20 / ONB #20	PV 7 — risk.md F1	✅	✅	✅ — shared index, verbal directive survival 0/1	✅ — external corpora read at pinned commits, never staged; TFW-55 dirty files excluded from the commit (verified: ecfceee touches no TFW-55 path)
21	HL #21 / ONB #21	PV 7 — constraint.md F1, F3	✅	✅	✅	✅ — no personal state in tree; template edits limited to the abbreviation field
22–28	HL #22–#28 / ONB #22–#28	RES 1 external — YAML 1.2.2, RFC 8259, Git docs, Drive/OneDrive/Dropbox, five agent frameworks	not re-fetched this review (external; unchanged since the baseline; RES-1 inputs)	—	—	✅ — ONB marks 22, 23, 25–28 N/A with a stated boundary (schema, journal carrier and transport untouched; TFW-61 owns sync) and 24 Applied (pinned commits isolate dirty corpora). The N/A reasoning is correct: Phase AB changes no carrier these items governed
29	HL #29 / ONB #29	RES 2 — git-interpret-trailers, git-log, git-merge-base	not re-fetched	—	—	✅ — "Applied in part": reachability of pinned commits; landing derivation unchanged
N1	ONB new	conventions.md §15 · release.md	✅	✅	✅ — release.md → Coordinator, "version bump → CHANGELOG → tag"	✅ — decided Q2
N2	ONB new	glossary.md Task Naming · compilable_contract.md §2	✅	✅	✅	✅ — decided Q1's census
N3	ONB new	conventions.md §10.3	✅	✅	✅ — templates and contract are upstream-owned payload	✅ — why the live config alone does not deliver AC-3

Priorities 0 and 1 are recorded as distinct items (HL #1–#2 vs #3–#5) and checked separately: 0 against purpose/principle clauses (NS1, NS2.3, NS2.5), 1 against methodology-value clauses (Structural Enforcement, Portability, one owner per truth). No citation resolves to an absent, wrong or irrelevant item. Total: 32 (29 + N1–N3) · resolved: 32 (24 opened locally, 8 external accepted as unchanged RES inputs) · semantically verified: 32 · irrelevant: 0 · hallucinated: 0.

Checkpoint

Self-check: - [x] Opened ≥ ⌈N × ratio⌉ files and recorded findings? — 31 of 31 (100%, escalated on D1) - [x] Ran at least 1 build/test command (or documented why not)? — 10 commands - [x] Claim & Source Checks filled — C1–C7; one ❌ (C7), one ⚠️ (C5) - [x] Each RF §3 (AC) checkmark verified against actual file? — yes; AC-2 and AC-6 carry D1 and D2 - [x] KNOWLEDGE.md checked — contradictions with changes documented? — D68 and §3 Legacy row 2 still declare YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS__slug current and the event suffix an actor (RF O1); routed to /tfw-docs per D37. KNOWLEDGE.md:22 docs/scripts/gen_index.py path is TD-186, pre-existing - [x] Knowledge Citations from HL §7.2 and ONB §7 verified — Total: 32, resolved: 32, semantically verified: 32, irrelevant: 0, hallucinated: 0 - [x] Evidence artifacts from RF §5 verified — Total evidence items: 9, verified: 8, partial: 1 (E3 collision clause is text, not a run), missing: 0

Stage complete: YES