title: "Map — "What was done?" (revision 2 — the REVISE correction round)" source: "tasks/TFW-60__conflict_resistant_shared_workspace/phase-ab/review/rev2/map.md"
Map — "What was done?" (revision 2 — the REVISE correction round)¶
Mindset: Experienced newcomer. Understand before you judge. RF: RF Phase AB, revision 2 — commit
4846f27TS: TS Phase AB, revision 2 — unchanged since the first review Prior review: REVIEW revision 1 — 🔄 REVISE on D1 and D2; stage files inreview/Master HL at contract baseline:810b1b8, unchanged Reviewer: Claude Code,on_behalf_of: saubakirov,via: claude-code
Understanding¶
One executor commit, 4846f27 (10 files: 3 implementation paths, 2 byte copies, 5 work artifacts). It closes the two REVISE items exactly as asked and nothing else: the string constant **Unaccounted: 0.** and its two test assertions are deleted, so the ## Guarantees checked table is now the manifest's only guarantee rendering; the two sentences claiming both temporary update directories are gitignored are deleted from update.md and its two full copies, leaving the file at 840 words. It also writes the phase journal event the first round lacked (TD-205), clock-read at 10:38:47, stating in its summary that it records the earlier missing execution → RF handoff without back-dating. The EV's E3 row now says the collision rule was "verified as text", which is what verify.md asked for. TD-200 and TD-201 — the reviewer's recommendation to the coordinator — were not taken into this round; the RF says so explicitly, and the TS carries no revision 3.
TS ↔ RF Alignment (delta only)¶
| REVIEW rev1 item | RF rev2 claim | Aligned? |
|---|---|---|
| D1 — delete the constant or compute it; remove the two literal assertions | "Deleted the redundant Unaccounted: 0 sentence and the two assertions that enshrined it" |
✅ |
| D2 — remove or make true the gitignore claim; stay under 1200 words; re-sync copies | "Deleted both claims … re-synced the two approved full copies … 840 words" | ✅ |
| TD-205 — one clock-read event on re-entry stating the gap | journal/20260830-103847__transition__6544.md |
✅ |
| E3 collision clause should say "verified as text" | EV E3 rewritten | ✅ |
| TD-200 / TD-201 — coordinator's call | "remain reviewer-filed follow-up work" | ✅ — filed, not taken; consistent with no TS revision |
| AC-1 … AC-8 from the first round | unchanged code paths except the deleted lines | carried from rev1 |
Deviations from TS¶
None. No path outside the first round's 23 was touched; budget moves from 1029 to 1027 counted lines.
Checkpoint¶
- [x] Read RF §1-§5 completely (revision 2 header, correction table, §4 figures, §5 pointer)
- [x] Read TS DoD and matched each item to RF §3 — unchanged from rev1; the two AC gates that carried findings re-checked below
- [x] HL §7 Principles — unchanged baseline
- [x] ONB — no new questions; the round needed none
Stage complete: YES