REVIEW — TFW-47 / Phase A: Evidence Enforcement¶
Date: 2026-07-17 Author: Reviewer (Antigravity) Verdict: ✅ APPROVE Review Mode: docs RF: RF Phase A TS: TS Phase A Stage files:
review/map.md,review/verify.md,review/judge.mdThis file is a synthesis of stage findings. Reference stage files for raw evidence.
1. Map¶
Phase A makes evidence/ a mandatory subfolder in every TFW task directory, replacing the optional policy from D16 (TFW-46). The executor created an EV template at .tfw/templates/evidence/EV.md (Environment header + per-AC table + Verdict + Attachments) and updated 5 framework files: conventions.md §3/§4/§14, TS template (Evidence Artifacts subsection), RF template §5 (pointer to EV file), handoff.md Step 11 (6-step evidence creation), and KNOWLEDGE.md (D53 — revokes D16, extends D52). Three positive deviations: D53 as separate decision (better trace), ### placement (avoids renumbering), and §3 pipeline table rows (clarifies cognitive modes).
2. Verify¶
| # | What was checked | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | EV template exists with all structural elements | ✅ | File at .tfw/templates/evidence/EV.md — 5 Environment fields, 6-column table, Verdict format, Attachments section, naming convention |
| V2 | conventions.md §3 mandatory language | ✅ | "MUST contain" at L114, no "optional"/"only when binary" (grep: 0 hits) |
| V3 | conventions.md §4 folder structure + naming | ✅ | 2 EV rows in naming table (L146-147), evidence subfolder section (L219-221), multi-phase structure (L237-238) |
| V4 | TS template Evidence Artifacts section | ✅ | ### Evidence Artifacts at L63 with guidance and example table |
| V5 | RF template §5 pointer format | ✅ | Pointer at L44, cognitive mode updated, verdict preserved, no inline table |
| V6 | handoff.md Step 11 substeps | ✅ | 6 substeps (L86-91), no skip condition (grep: 0 hits), RF §5 pointer instruction |
| V7 | KNOWLEDGE.md D53 + D16 revocation | ✅ | D53 at L84 with "Revokes TFW-46 research D16", 0/38 justification |
| V8 | conventions.md §14 anti-patterns | ✅ | Evidence anti-patterns at L442-446, "evidence/" folder language present |
| V9 | EV evidence file for this phase | ✅ | evidence/EV__phase-a__evidence_enforcement.md exists, 6 N/A rows, verdict matches RF §5 |
| V10 | Knowledge citations (KC1-KC9) | ✅ | All 9 citations resolve to real items, 0 hallucinations |
All 6 files verified (100%). Full log:
review/verify.md.
3. Judge¶
| # | Check | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? | ✅ | All 6 ACs verified against actual files. 0 discrepancies. |
| 2 | Philosophy aligned | ✅ | P1 (mandatory): "MUST contain" in conventions. P2 (values): structured template with Environment/table/Verdict. |
| 3 | Tech debt documented | ✅ | 3 observations in RF §6 — compilable_contract Source Manifest, project_config.yaml templates, review template references. All substantive. |
| 4 | Style & standards | ✅ | EV naming follows D28 (2-letter abbreviation). Section hierarchy, language style consistent with existing framework docs. |
| 5 | Observations collected | ✅ | 3 items, all typed, all real issues (not filler). Quality filter passed. |
| 6 | RF completeness (§7-9) | ✅ | §7 Fact Candidates: present, empty (valid). §8 Strategic Insights: present, empty (valid). §9 Diagrams: BEFORE/AFTER ascii diagram showing evidence pipeline change. |
| 7 | Evidence completeness | ✅ | All TS AC items Evidence: N/A (definition documents). EV file exists with correct all-N/A verdict. Appropriate for methodology changes. |
| 8 | Content quality (docs) | ✅ | Clear language, self-documenting template, actionable handoff substeps. |
| 9 | Source verification (docs) | ✅ | D53 cites 0/38 metric from HL. Template aligns with iter1 RES D1-D7. |
4. Verdict¶
✅ APPROVE
All 6 acceptance criteria met. 100% file verification — zero discrepancies. The EV template is well-designed: structured enough for traceability (Environment header, per-AC table with 4-status vocabulary, Verdict summary) yet flexible enough for diverse tasks (proportionality via row count, "(if applicable)" fields). Three deviations from TS are all positive improvements (D53 as separate decision preserving trace, ### placement avoiding renumber, pipeline table rows clarifying cognitive modes). Knowledge citations verified — 9/9 resolve, 0 hallucinations. Evidence file follows the new convention (the task itself is evidence that the template works).
5. Tech Debt Collected¶
| # | Source | Severity | File | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TD-1 | RF §6 Obs #1 | Low | .tfw/compilable_contract.md |
Source Manifest doesn't include EV template path. Phase D should consider adding. | → Phase D or backlog |
| TD-2 | RF §6 Obs #2 | Low | .tfw/project_config.yaml |
tfw.templates section doesn't list EV template. Consistent with research templates not listed either — convention, not bug. |
→ backlog |
Observation #3 (review/verify.md references) correctly assessed as no-action: RF §5 pointer means artifact paths still resolve. Not promoted to tech debt.
6. Traces Updated¶
- [x] README Task Board — status updated to 📚 KNW (A)
- [x] TECH_DEBT.md — TD-120, TD-121 appended
- [x] tfw-docs: N/A (minor methodology phase — no architecture changes beyond what D53 already captured)
- [x] tfw-knowledge: N/A (no fact candidates in RF, no human insights in this phase)
7. Fact Candidates¶
No fact candidates.
REVIEW — TFW-47 / Phase A: Evidence Enforcement | 2026-07-17