REVIEW — Tech Debt Quick Fixes (post TFW-29)¶
Date: 2026-04-09 Author: Reviewer (AI) Verdict: ✅ APPROVE — all items resolved (REVISE item fixed) Commits:
f566d97(8 items),8f4e746(11 items)
1. Review Checklist¶
| # | Check | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? (all claimed TD items resolved) | ✅ | TD-84 complete — all 7 template files updated (3 remaining fixed in revision) |
| 2 | Code quality | ✅ | All changes follow existing patterns and formatting |
| 3 | Test coverage | N/A | No code logic changes |
| 4 | Philosophy aligned | ✅ | Single Source of Truth maintained — refs consolidated, duplicates removed |
| 5 | Tech debt (shortcuts?) | ✅ | No new shortcuts taken |
| 6 | Security | N/A | Documentation only |
| 7 | Breaking changes | ✅ | No references broken. handoff.md anti-patterns correctly reduced to ref + role-specific. KNOWLEDGE.md refs converted to reference format |
| 8 | Style & standards | ✅ | Consistent formatting across all changes |
| 9 | Observations collected | N/A | Quick fixes, not a formal task |
Item-by-Item Verification¶
Commit 1: f566d97 — 8 items¶
| TD | Claim | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| TD-12 | REVIEW template {coordinator} → {reviewer} |
✅ | REVIEW.md L3 now says {reviewer} |
| TD-50 | conventions.md §2 add config.md | ✅ | Line 36: config.md — interactive config change workflow |
| TD-51 | PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml add config workflow | ✅ | config: .tfw/workflows/config.md added |
| TD-57 | config.md Russian → English | ✅ | "Что хотите изменить" → "What would you like to change", "Применить?" → "Apply?" |
| TD-62 | Hard Stop Rule add Researcher→Coordinator | ✅ | Lines 317-320: Researcher transition with correct instruction |
| TD-84 | Templates §16.2 → compilable_contract.md §2 | ✅ | Fixed: RES.md, REVIEW.md (×2), RF.md, TOPIC_FILE.md, HL.md, ONB.md, TS.md — all 7 files updated |
| TD-85 | conventions.md §9 add .agent/rules | ✅ | Line 206: .agent/rules ──→ "Read .tfw/README.md..." |
| TD-86 | glossary.md FC/Strategic Insight → Knowledge Terms | ✅ | Line 42: ## Knowledge Terms section created, both entries moved under it |
Commit 2: 8f4e746 — 11 items¶
| TD | Claim | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| TD-37 | conventions.md §3 RES add Briefing/Closure | ✅ | Lines 51-52: "Produced via Briefing → Gather → Extract → Challenge stages. RES file = synthesis. Stage files = raw investigation." |
| TD-40 | Role Lock table verified correct | ✅ | Verification-only item — status change is appropriate |
| TD-46 | init.md Phase 5 verified: no broken refs | ✅ | Verification-only item |
| TD-49 | handoff.md anti-patterns → ref + role-specific | ✅ | Lines 137-141: ref to §14, only 3 executor-specific items remain |
| TD-53 | review.md "project knowledge" → "strategic knowledge" | ✅ | Lines 82-83: "strategic knowledge — domain insights, stakeholder priorities..." |
| TD-61 | glossary RESEARCH remove skip duplication | ✅ | Line 92: "Optional — user can skip with confirmation" removed |
| TD-64 | RF template category list → ref to §10.1 | ✅ | Line 69: "see conventions.md §10.1 for full list" |
| TD-65 | KNOWLEDGE.md template verified LF | ✅ | Verification-only item |
| TD-66 | KNOWLEDGE.md backtick paths → reference format | ✅ | D1-D8 + §2 Key Artifacts all converted from tasks/TFW-X.../...md to RF TFW-X, HL-TFW-X format |
| TD-67 | knowledge/*.md verified already uses ref format | ✅ | Verification-only item |
| TD-83 | KNOWLEDGE.md §16 refs → compilable_contract.md | ✅ | P10, D34, Architecture Map all updated. Grep confirms 0 remaining §16 refs in KNOWLEDGE.md |
2. Verdict¶
✅ APPROVE — all 19 items resolved
All items correctly resolved. TD-84 revision completed — HL.md, ONB.md, TS.md updated to match the pattern in RES.md, REVIEW.md, RF.md, TOPIC_FILE.md. The KNOWLEDGE.md reference format migration (TD-66) is particularly well-done — clean conversion from backtick paths to the compilable contract's reference format.
3. Tech Debt Collected¶
No new tech debt from these fixes.
4. Traces Updated¶
- [x] TECH_DEBT.md — TD-84 status ✅ (all 7 files fixed)
REVIEW — TD Quick Fixes (post TFW-29) | 2026-04-09