Skip to content

REVIEW — TFW-10: Version String Sweep

Date: 2026-03-14 Author: Reviewer Verdict: ✅ APPROVE RF: RF__TFW-10 TS: TS__TFW-10

1. Review Checklist

# Check Status Notes
1 DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria) ✅ All 5 criteria verified — see §1 detail below
2 Code quality (conventions, naming, type hints) ✅ Documentation-only task; files follow existing formatting
3 Test coverage (tests written and passing) N/A No code changed; grep audit substitutes for test suite
4 Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy) ✅ Minimal diff applied; Evolution section preserved as specified in HL §7
5 Tech debt (shortcuts documented?) ✅ Scope-budget exception (10 files > 7) documented in ONB §5 and RF §2 Key Decision 3
6 Security (no secrets exposed, guards in place) N/A Documentation-only
7 Breaking changes (backward compat, migrations) ✅ Downstream-drift risk for already-copied adapter files noted in RF Observation 1; no action required in this repo
8 Style & standards (code style, conventions) ✅ Replacements are surgical; no structural changes to any file
9 Observations collected (executor reported findings) ✅ 1 observation in RF §5; adequately described

DoD Criterion Verification (TS §5)

Criterion Result Evidence
grep -rn "TFW v3" .tfw/init.md .tfw/conventions.md .tfw/glossary.md .tfw/adapters README.md AGENTS.md → 0 results ✅ Reviewer grep run: 0 results
.tfw/README.md Evolution section unchanged ✅ grep -n "v3 —" .tfw/README.md → L276 ### v3 — Tool-Agnostic Core (2026) only
PR opened against master ✅ RF §3, commit 7a1cadb; fork-based PR VadimJCA:fix/version-string-sweep → saubakirov:master
No functional content altered ✅ All changes are literal TFW v3 → TFW 0.4 string subs; structure/logic unchanged
Commit message references TFW-10 ✅ RF §3 confirms

Notes

  • The two TFW v3 hits in README.md (lines 112, 120) are Task Board descriptive text (Upgrade to TFW v3 task title and Replace stale "TFW v3" labels task description), not version labels. Correct to leave untouched.
  • RF correctly calls out 20 replacements across 10 files. HL counted 14 occurrences in 8 files; the delta (6 more, 2 more files) is accounted for by README.md (3 occurrences: H1, line 75, line 95) and AGENTS.md (1 occurrence) — both listed in TS §3 but not in the HL count table. Count is consistent end-to-end.
  • Key Decision 1 (use TFW 0.4 not TFW 0.4.2 in headings) is well-reasoned and aligns with HL §3 rationale.
  • ONB Recommendation 2 (AGENTS.md: drop version entirely rather than substitute 0.4) was implemented. Verified: AGENTS.md line 4 now reads Follow TFW conventions…. This is a minor, sensible deviation from the TS literal (Follow TFW 0.4…); it is strictly better (downstream projects copying this file won't inherit a stale version label). Deviation acceptable.

2. Verdict

✅ APPROVE

All TS acceptance criteria are met. The grep audit confirms zero stale TFW v3 version strings in scope. The Evolution section is intact. The PR is open. No functional content was altered. Observations are reported and constitute low-severity tech debt only. The AGENTS.md deviation (dropping version label rather than substituting TFW 0.4) is an improvement over the TS literal.

3. Tech Debt Collected

# Source Severity File Description Action
1 TFW-10 RF obs. 1 Low .tfw/adapters/antigravity/tfw-rules.md.template Downstream projects that already copied this template will still have TFW v3 in their .agent/rules/tfw.md until they re-copy from the updated template. No automated migration exists. → backlog; document in adapter README or release notes

4. Traces Updated

  • [x] README Task Board — TFW-10 status updated: 🟢 RF → ✅ DONE
  • [x] TECH_DEBT.md — TD-19 appended (downstream adapter drift)
  • [ ] HL status — N/A, single-phase task; HL was draft-only
  • [ ] PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml — N/A
  • [x] tfw-docs: N/A (minor documentation sweep; KNOWLEDGE.md does not need update)

REVIEW — TFW-10: Version String Sweep | 2026-03-14