Verify — “Are the corrected claims true?” (revision 2)

Mindset: Auditor. This is a full rerun, not a delta review. Test: “If RF and the first review disappeared, would the current product and evidence prove the frozen contract?” Minimum product ratio: 0.42; required minimum: ceil(35 × 0.42) = 15. Actual product verification: 35/35 paths (100%). Actual evidence verification: 47/47 attachments inspected (100%); 39 fully support their bounded claims, 8 partial/overclaiming, 0 missing.

Verification boundary

• Contract baseline: ee09a8a5bf...; product comparison baseline: f3eb986.
• Corrected terminal package: b37f7a3, 964abd2, 85d4e76; current HEAD is 85d4e76d7b3ae0f9f7e439b329250527d8bc3f71.
• The first-pass review/{map,verify,judge}.md and formal REVISE remain unchanged. This pass writes only under review/rev2/.
• Literal f3eb986..HEAD includes 60 paths outside editions/ and this task workspace from concurrent TFW-60/root work. An independent task-attributed audit enumerated all 17 Assisted commits and found 0 forbidden-path hits. The literal and attributed audits are both retained; concurrent changes are not reclassified as Assisted work.
• editions/ remains exactly 35 product paths: 25 added, 7 modified, 3 deleted; 2,871 additions + 778 removals = 3,649 changed lines, below the 4,800 ceiling. git diff --check f3eb986 -- editions passes.
• Reviewer diagnostic commands briefly created an ignored Python cache and rewrote two evidence summaries through verify_task.py; the cache was removed and both tracked evidence files were restored byte-exactly to HEAD before continuing. No product, RF, EV, HL, TS, ONB, status or journal artifact was changed.

Product verification — 35/35

#	Product path	Independent result
1	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-handoff/SKILL.md	Complete bounded Executor/partial-history/Coordinator-reporting contract; matches frozen lifecycle.
2	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-handoff/agents/openai.yaml	Valid complete metadata pair.
3	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-identity/SKILL.md	Documented --organization-role command now executes, but the promised per-operation locality defense is not fully implemented before the first registry read; see D10.
4	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-identity/agents/openai.yaml	Valid fail-closed metadata.
5	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-identity/scripts/tfw_identity.py	Stock 23-check matrix passes and corrected full-chain/ACL fixtures pass; independent call-order instrumentation exposes D10.
6	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-plan/SKILL.md	One-Coordinator/one-Executor/one-Reviewer, same-role reuse, manual fallback and acceptance boundary present.
7	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-plan/agents/openai.yaml	Valid metadata.
8	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-review/SKILL.md	Full-contract repeat review and Reviewer no-fix role lock present.
9	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-review/agents/openai.yaml	Valid metadata.
10	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-update/SKILL.md	Manifest/provenance/confinement corrections are documented; its project-lock guarantee is not met across distinct operations; see D9.
11	editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-update/agents/openai.yaml	Valid metadata.
12	editions/02-assisted/.codex/hooks.json	Deleted; exact accepted stock hook only.
13	editions/02-assisted/.codex/hooks/tfw-hook.ps1	Deleted; exact accepted stock hook only.
14	editions/02-assisted/.codex/hooks/tfw-hook.sh	Deleted; exact accepted stock hook only.
15	editions/02-assisted/AGENTS.md	Neutral Russian-authoritative Assisted 1.5, manual baseline and truthful capability limits.
16	editions/02-assisted/CHANGELOG.md	Useful public changelog: 1.5 — Unreleased plus public 1.0 baseline only; no false tag/release history.
17	editions/02-assisted/MIGRATION.md	Complete protected-state/manual migration and exact hook retirement guidance.
18	editions/02-assisted/PROJECT.md	Visibly uninitialized; no plausible organization/project/person defaults.
19	editions/02-assisted/README.md	Standalone lifecycle, initialization, templates, identity and maintenance entry points are readable and mutually consistent.
20	editions/02-assisted/VERSION	Exact bytes 1.5\n.
21	editions/02-assisted/knowledge/INDEX.md	Neutral empty knowledge navigation; no Innoforce knowledge.
22	editions/02-assisted/people/README.md	Neutral empty people navigation and identity/role distinction.
23	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/assets/tfw-mark.svg	Shape-only SVG; no text, metadata, event, URL, script or private marker.
24	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/build_a4.py	Stock/custom and six hostile checks pass twice; offline bounded builder.
25	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/overlay/theme.css	One :root, six declared generic properties.
26	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/theme.css	One :root, six declared generic properties.
27	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/документ_A4.md	Complete useful Russian example with long heading/token, code, lists and wide/tall tables.
28	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/заметка.md	Complete generic note; only non-blocking Markdown spacing polish remains.
29	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/план_работы.md	Complete result/scope/acceptance/risk/rollback example.
30	editions/02-assisted/шаблоны/презентация.html	Five readable local Russian slides, no external dependency.
31	editions/ASSISTED_MAINTENANCE.md	Direction/manifest/reverse guidance is clear, but the asserted cross-operation project lock is ineffective; see D9.
32	editions/README.md	Edition selection and Assisted 1.5 capability boundary are accurate.
33	editions/maintenance/assisted_maintenance.py	Corrected D1–D6 behaviors pass; a new hostile concurrent-operation fixture disproves the project-lock claim; see D9.
34	editions/maintenance/maintenance-policy.json	Canonical, deterministic and uniquely classifying; exact three retirement hashes and manifest authority hold.
35	editions/maintenance/release-manifest.json	Stored 31 payload entries exactly equal independent regeneration; repeated public hashes stable.

Commands and independent reruns

Check	Result
verify-release --source-root editions, twice	Exit 0 both times; manifest 3697803d…4156624b, policy 2caf8bba…3d64b07, byte-stable.
Fresh full maintenance self-test	Exit 0; V1–V12 report true; omitted payload/policy, unexpected/self/nonregular, operation link, reverse fake/public-root, next-source and seven role cases all report true.
Fresh identity self-test	Exit 0; V7/V8 and all 23 declared checks true, including actual private ACL, full namespace pin, junction/substitution/root-swap/live-lock cases.
A4 builder self-test, twice	Exit 0 twice; all six static/stock/custom/attack checks true.
Task evidence runner	Exit 0 and reproduced the retained public hash, but its execution writes evidence summaries; those diagnostic writes were restored. Its matrix omission is recorded under D9/D10 rather than treated as proof.
.tfw/scripts/gen_index.py --check tasks / --check project	Exit 0 / exit 0. --check index reports stale shared workspace/00-INDEX.md; this is concurrent shared aggregate state outside the frozen product boundary and was not edited by the Reviewer.
Manifest regeneration after cache cleanup	31/31 exact entries; stored/generated equality restored; no __pycache__ remains.
D1 hostile omitted real payload	Rejected with release manifest paths differ from regenerated allowed payload.
D2 forward manifest continuity	verified=true, manifest carried byte-exact, resulting target verifies and is accepted as next source.
D3 real Windows junction parent	Rejected with operation directory parent ancestry contains a link or reparse point; zero target product write.
D5 reverse hostile provenance/confinement	Incomplete fake terminal and candidate under public root both reject at zero writes.
D6 role matrix	Exactly seven deterministic cases: complete, partial, lost-handle, no-interrupt, overlap, manual-fallback, full-re-review; all expected/observed records equal and duplicates=0.
D7 clean documented identity command	create-profile --organization-role ... exits 0 and creates the expected Latin handle in a clean copy.
D8 render validation	Four PDFs parse as 3+3+5+5 pages; PDF text has no local URL; all 20 replacements have true PNG signatures and retained hashes.
D9 independent held-lock fixture	lock_paths_equal=false; a second operation with the same target but another operation directory returns second_status=verified while the first alleged project lock remains held.
D10 call-order instrumentation	call_order=read_registry->reprobe; therefore registry access occurs before the first operation-time revalidation.
Relative link audit	HL: 16 links, 0 missing; ONB: 2 links, 0 missing. All ten PV sources and twenty HL/ONB citation applications were read semantically.
Privacy/neutrality scan and manual read	No field organization, private payload/history/path/brand/person projected into product. Hits are only the deliberately split forbidden scanner strings and generic provider label Shared Drives; SVG/CSS remain neutral.
H: post-review read-only inventory	Actual source H:\Shared drives\IT\Innoforce AI-First Knowledge\innoforce_starter_v1.5: 29 files; PowerShell culture digest 7e2248a7…4fadc3, Python code-point digest 3a1885c6…dbee96b; both equal retained pre/post.
Live role tree	Exactly one Phase Coordinator, the same completed Executor, and this same independent Reviewer; no duplicate task role session.
Git publication audit	85d4e76 is in no remote-tracking branch and no tag; no Assisted correction commit is published. No push/tag command was run by this Reviewer.

Closure of original D1–D8

Historical finding	Full-rerun result
D1 manifest completeness	Closed: exact regenerated payload equality and all five hostile manifest cases reject.
D2 forward manifest	Closed: separately journaled/carried byte-exact; target and next-source verification pass.
D3 operation link	Closed: actual Windows junction ancestry rejects before target product write.
D4 identity chain/ACL	Closed for the corrected tested cases: full created namespace chain and private owner/ACL are proven; permissive ACL/substitution/junction/root swap reject. D10 is a distinct first-read ordering defect.
D5 reverse provenance/confinement	Closed: canonical neighboring terminal/journal and exact outside candidate root required; fabricated/public-root cases reject.
D6 role matrix	Closed: deterministic seven-scenario record exists and passes; live lineage separately verified.
D7 documented identity flag	Closed: one flag name throughout and clean documented execution succeeds.
D8 rendered evidence	Closed: all 20 actual PNGs visually opened; no header/footer/local URL, byte mismatch, seam, clipping or unreadable glyph/table/token found.

New discrepancies

D9 — Critical — “project lock” is unique per operation, not shared per target

• Requirement: TS AC-3 line 99 requires a project lock immediately before mutation; AC-11 lines 193–200 require complete race/conflicting-writer coverage; frozen HL DoF 7 forbids silently merging a conflicting writer.
• Location: editions/maintenance/assisted_maintenance.py:644-647. The target-derived key is stable, but lock_path = operation / f"project-{lock_key}.lock". execute_forward creates each operation directory independently at lines 615–627, so two operations for one target lock two different files.
• Independent reproduction: hold ProjectLock(<held-operation>/project-<same-target>.lock), then call execute_forward for the same target with <second-operation>. Output: lock_paths_equal=false, second_status=verified, second_completed_while_first_lock_held=true.
• Impact: the OS lock provides no mutual exclusion between normal distinct operations. Two maintenance writers can both pass the claimed project-lock gate; baseline/per-path checks may detect some races but cannot replace the explicitly required lock or guarantee conflict prevention.
• Correction request: locate the lock in a stable, private and pinned lock root keyed by the canonical pinned target identity and independent of the unique operation directory; acquire it before the complete target baseline/staging/mutation sequence. Add a real two-operation/two-process fixture proving distinct operation directories contend and the loser performs zero product writes. Preserve operation journals as create-once per-operation records.

D10 — High — identity registry is read before operation-time locality revalidation

• Requirement: TS AC-8 lines 155–165 permits persistent binding only when the full locality/ACL/component evidence is revalidated at every operation, including substitution defense; AC-7 requires unsafe state to avoid persistent identity access/state.
• Location: editions/02-assisted/.agents/skills/tfw-identity/scripts/tfw_identity.py:495-500 calls read_registry(store) before reprobe(decision) in update_registry. The command path also performs a redundant read_registry at lines 761–764 before its first re-probe.
• Independent reproduction: replace read_registry and reprobe with order-recording probes and stop at the first re-probe. Actual output is call_order=read_registry->reprobe, read_before_first_reprobe=true.
• Impact: after locality is initially proven, an ancestor/namespace substitution may redirect the first existence/file/read access before the saved chain is checked. Later re-probes protect the write path, but they do not satisfy “revalidated at every operation” before the first registry access and do not close the bounded privacy/race claim.
• Correction request: re-probe the complete pinned chain and re-check private ACL/owner evidence before any registry or lock exists, type check or byte read; remove the redundant pre-read in the command dispatcher and perform all binding reads under the validated lock where applicable. Add a fixture that substitutes the namespace after locality() but before the first read and asserts both zero read of the substituted registry and zero persistent write.

No frozen-HL amendment is indicated: both defects are repairable inside the existing five affected product paths and task-local evidence boundary.

Evidence attachment verification — 47/47

“Full” means the attachment accurately supports its bounded claim. “Partial” includes an accurate recorded run whose completeness conclusion is disproved by D9/D10.

#	Attachment	Result
1	assisted15-fixture-results.json	Partial — recorded outputs are reproducible, but V3/V8/V11 completeness omits D9/D10.
2	assisted15-verification.log	Partial — commands and hashes reproduce; terminal PASS overstates the frozen race matrix.
3	boundary-and-source-attestation.md	Partial — boundary/source/publication facts hold; “project lock pass” is disproved by D9.
4	boundary-summary.json	Partial — retained census/environment are accurate at capture; fixture_all_v1_v12 is not complete against D9/D10 and current dual audit is 17 task commits.
5	EV__TFW_20260830-114238_ASSISTED15.md	Partial — E1/E2/E4–E7/E9/E10 facts hold, but E3/E8/E11 overclaim D9/D10; E12 dependency is not closed.
6	identity-windows.json	Partial — actual recorded ACL/junction/substitution/lock observations hold, but there is no pre-first-read revalidation fixture.
7	maintenance/forward-journal.ndjson	Full — canonical 35 planned path records including the separate manifest; actual operation trace.
8	maintenance/forward-terminal.json	Full — canonical create-once verified record for that bounded operation.
9	maintenance/partial-journal.ndjson	Full — started plus one path event for injected failure.
10	maintenance/partial-terminal.json	Full — canonical immutable partial terminal.
11	maintenance/protected-after.json	Full — eight protected entries byte-equal.
12	maintenance/protected-before.json	Full — eight protected entries and hashes resolve.
13	maintenance/public-candidate-a.json	Full — canonical privacy-safe candidate for a valid closed operation.
14	maintenance/public-candidate-b.json	Full — byte-identical projection/public ID from a distinct valid operation.
15	maintenance/recovery-terminal.json	Full — separate linked verified recovery record.
16	run_evidence.py	Partial — reproducible generator, but the race/locality matrix lacks D9/D10.
17	source-immutability.json	Full — both independent current 29-row digests match retained pre/post and the algorithm distinction is correct.
18	templates/a4-custom.html	Full — standalone Russian HTML, no external resources.
19	templates/a4-custom.pdf	Full — valid complete three-page header-free PDF and retained hash.
20	templates/a4-custom-page-1.png	Full — true PNG; visually readable.
21	templates/a4-custom-page-2.png	Full — true PNG; long token/table content readable.
22	templates/a4-custom-page-3.png	Full — true PNG; final table/footer clean.
23	templates/a4-stock.html	Full — standalone Russian HTML, no external resources.
24	templates/a4-stock.pdf	Full — valid complete three-page header-free PDF and retained hash.
25	templates/a4-stock-page-1.png	Full — true PNG; readable.
26	templates/a4-stock-page-2.png	Full — true PNG; readable.
27	templates/a4-stock-page-3.png	Full — true PNG; final table/footer clean.
28	templates/browser-a4-custom-full.png	Full — true single-shot PNG, no stitch overlap or local URL.
29	templates/browser-a4-stock-full.png	Full — true single-shot PNG, no stitch overlap.
30	templates/browser-presentation-custom-full.png	Full — true single-shot PNG covering all five slides without seam duplication.
31	templates/browser-presentation-stock-full.png	Full — true single-shot PNG covering all five slides without seam duplication.
32	templates/presentation-custom.html	Full — five local Russian slides; no external resources.
33	templates/presentation-custom.pdf	Full — valid complete five-page PDF and retained hash.
34	templates/presentation-custom-page-1.png	Full — true PNG; readable.
35	templates/presentation-custom-page-2.png	Full — true PNG; two-column content readable.
36	templates/presentation-custom-page-3.png	Full — true PNG; long token/glyphs readable.
37	templates/presentation-custom-page-4.png	Full — true PNG; table readable.
38	templates/presentation-custom-page-5.png	Full — true PNG; list readable.
39	templates/presentation-stock.html	Full — five local Russian slides; no external resources.
40	templates/presentation-stock.pdf	Full — valid complete five-page PDF and retained hash.
41	templates/presentation-stock-page-1.png	Full — true PNG; readable.
42	templates/presentation-stock-page-2.png	Full — true PNG; two-column content readable.
43	templates/presentation-stock-page-3.png	Full — true PNG; long token/glyphs readable.
44	templates/presentation-stock-page-4.png	Full — true PNG; table readable.
45	templates/presentation-stock-page-5.png	Full — true PNG; list readable.
46	templates/render-summary.json	Full — independent signature/hash/page/visual checks match all bounded fields.
47	verify_task.py	Partial — boundary/census checks are useful, but it trusts the incomplete shipped race/locality matrix and mutates retained summaries when run.

Evidence totals: 47 inspected; 39 full (82.98%); 8 partial/overclaiming (17.02%); 0 missing.

Knowledge citations — 20/20

The ten frozen sources were checked once at source and twice at their HL/ONB application. All 20 applications resolve, exist, preserve the source meaning and remain relevant.

Citation pair	Source and semantic result
HL/ONB K1	README.md How It Works — proportional discipline/continuity; valid.
HL/ONB K2	.tfw/README.md NS1/NS3 — human-governed continuity and non-goals; valid.
HL/ONB K3	.tfw/README.md methodology values/Success Criteria — structural, portable, resumable, acceptance-ready; valid.
HL/ONB K4	knowledge/philosophy.md F32–F34 — preserve meaning and reach a usable result; valid.
HL/ONB K5	KNOWLEDGE.md D57–D60 — topology and honest capability boundary; valid. D58’s older hook state is explicitly treated as superseded, not copied as a current claim.
HL/ONB K6	.tfw/conventions.md §§3, 11, 14 — structural gates, evidence honesty and no scope drift; valid and directly material to D9/D10.
HL/ONB K7	knowledge/convention.md F20 — uninitialized starter state is product behavior; valid.
HL/ONB K8	knowledge/constraint.md F10 — edition independence; valid.
HL/ONB K9	knowledge/process.md F27–F29 plus relevant F32 — routine discipline, real initialization, evidence/acceptance distinction and final recapture; valid.
HL/ONB K10	knowledge/stakeholder.md F4–F5/F8 — low-friction, non-redundant onboarding and clean deterministic checks; valid.

Totals: 20 resolved, 20 semantically verified, 0 irrelevant, 0 hallucinated.

Deferred evidence decisions

• E4 — closed by this verification. The live role tree is exactly one Phase Coordinator → the same completed Executor → this same independent Reviewer. Reports went to the Phase Coordinator, the first REVISE history is preserved, and the deterministic seven-scenario table passes.
• Semantic neutrality/privacy — accepted. Manual reading of all 35 product paths, private-marker scans, SVG/CSS inspection and all rendered outputs found no Innoforce knowledge, organization/person/brand/logo/private-history/path payload in the product. Generic provider terminology and scanner literals are functional, not field projection.
• E12 field-source immutability — accepted. The real 29-file H: source was read only; both current aggregate digests equal the retained pre/post values. The two hashes differ solely because PowerShell culture order and Python code-point order serialize the same rows differently.
• E12 no publication — accepted. No Assisted terminal commit is contained by a remote-tracking branch or tag; no push/tag/publication was run.
• E12 both-direction mechanics — demonstrated, but E12 cannot close as a whole. Forward reaches a verified maintainable 1.5 and reverse remains candidate-only with corrected provenance/confinement. However AC-12 depends on AC-3 and AC-11, and D9 leaves the required cross-operation project-lock/race property unsatisfied.

Checkpoint

Self-check: - [x] Full rerun, not delta-only: 35/35 product paths and 47/47 attachments. - [x] Every original D1–D8 correction independently reopened and rerun. - [x] Critical V1–V12, identity, template, boundary, manifest, maintenance and hostile checks rerun. - [x] Every actual rendered image opened visually: 20/20. - [x] Both H: digest algorithms rerun read-only after verification. - [x] E4, E12, semantic neutrality/privacy and publication decided explicitly. - [x] Twenty HL/ONB knowledge-citation applications revalidated. - [x] Discrepancies have exact requirements, files/lines, reproductions, impact and bounded correction requests. - [x] Unrelated .gitignore, TFW-55 and concurrent shared state were preserved.

Stage complete: YES

WAIT — Verify is complete. Coordinator checkpoint is required before Purpose Check/Judge.