REVIEW — TFW-6 / Phase B: Workflows
Date: 2026-03-12
Author: Coordinator (AI)
Verdict: ✅ APPROVE
RF: RF Phase B
TS: TS Phase B
1. Review Checklist
| # |
Check |
Status |
Notes |
| 1 |
DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria) |
✅ |
All 8 items verified — see below |
| 2 |
Code quality (conventions, naming, type hints) |
✅ |
Markdown well-structured, YAML frontmatter present on all workflows |
| 3 |
Test coverage (tests written and passing) |
N/A |
No code — Markdown artifacts |
| 4 |
Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy) |
✅ |
General over specific (workflow vs RELEASE.md), plain text, adapter parity |
| 5 |
Tech debt (shortcuts documented?) |
✅ |
2 observations documented |
| 6 |
Security (no secrets exposed, guards in place) |
N/A |
No secrets |
| 7 |
Breaking changes (backward compat, migrations) |
✅ |
Additive only — new workflows and new glossary terms |
| 8 |
Style & standards (code style, conventions) |
✅ |
Consistent with existing workflow style (plan.md, handoff.md) |
| 9 |
Observations collected (executor reported findings) |
✅ |
2 valid observations |
Verification Details
| # |
Acceptance Criterion |
Result |
| 1 |
.tfw/workflows/release.md with YAML frontmatter + complete process |
✅ 7 steps, description frontmatter present |
| 2 |
.tfw/workflows/update.md with 🟢🟡🔴 categorization |
✅ 8 steps, categorization table in Step 3 |
| 3 |
.agent/workflows/tfw-release.md identical |
✅ Compare-Object returned no diff |
| 4 |
.agent/workflows/tfw-update.md identical |
✅ Compare-Object returned no diff |
| 5 |
conventions.md §8 includes release + update |
✅ Table has 5 rows (plan, handoff, resume, release, update) |
| 6 |
conventions.md §2 includes RELEASE.md as optional |
✅ Listed after KNOWLEDGE.md with _(optional)_ marker |
| 7 |
glossary.md has 5 new terms |
✅ VERSION, CHANGELOG.md, RELEASE.md, tfw-release, tfw-update — all present before §Project-Specific Terms |
| 8 |
Cross-references valid |
✅ All file paths and section references checked |
2. Verdict
✅ APPROVE
All deliverables match the TS spec exactly. Adapter copies are byte-identical. Workflow structure is consistent with existing canonical workflows. The tfw-release workflow cleanly separates general process from project context (RELEASE.md). The tfw-update workflow with 🟢🟡🔴 categorization provides a practical, actionable upgrade process.
3. Tech Debt Collected
| # |
Source |
Severity |
File |
Description |
Action |
| TD-7 |
RF obs. #1 |
Low |
.agent/workflows/ |
No Claude Code or Cursor adapter copies for release/update workflows |
→ backlog (future adapter task) |
| TD-8 |
RF obs. #2 |
Med |
.tfw/conventions.md §8 |
docs.md workflow not listed in Workflows table (predates Phase B, from TFW-5) |
→ backlog (resolves TD-4 partially — Phase C should fix this) |
4. Traces Updated
| *REVIEW — TFW-6 / Phase B: Workflows |
2026-03-12* |