Дата: 2026-04-03 Автор: Reviewer (AI) Статус: 🔍 REV Parent HL: HL-TFW-19 TS: TS-TFW-19 RF: RF-TFW-19
| # | Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? | ✅ | All 15 acceptance criteria verified against actual files |
| 2 | Code quality | ✅ | Standard 2-line header consistent across all 4 files; table format matches reference (research.md) |
| 3 | Test coverage | ✅ | Meta-project — grep verification in RF §4 correct; independent verification below |
| 4 | Philosophy aligned | ✅ | Pattern A (inline + config key) restores RESEARCH-12 recommendation. P1 (enforcement inline), P3 (no scripts) upheld |
| 5 | Tech debt | ✅ | TD-48 resolved. 3 new observations triaged below |
| 6 | Security | N/A | No secrets, no code |
| 7 | Observability | N/A | No code |
| 8 | Breaking changes | ⚠️ | See §2 |
| 9 | Style & standards | ✅ | Conventions followed, adapters byte-synced (diff = 0) |
RF claims 16 entries: 8 scope_budgets + 4 research + 4 knowledge = 16. Verified — all present in config.md §Config Sync Registry.
Observation: RF #2 correctly flags that PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml tfw.workflows section doesn’t include config.md. This is a legitimate consistency gap — the YAML lists 10 workflows but config.md is the 11th.
conventions.md §8 now lists 11 workflows (was 10). Downstream projects copying conventions from upstream will see the new entry. Not a breaking change per se, but notable for tfw-update — the diff will show the new row.
L27 now reads: **Бюджет:** {N} новых файлов, {M} модификаций. Defaults: max {max_files} files, max {max_new} new, max {max_loc} LOC.
The {max_files} etc. are template placeholders for the coordinator to fill from config when writing TS. This is correct — the coordinator reads config and substitutes. Not a runtime placeholder.
| Check | Command / Inspection | Result |
|---|---|---|
| plan.md budget table | view_file L116-127 |
✅ 4 rows, values match config (14, 8, 1200, 12) |
| plan.md enforcement hook | view_file L92-94 |
✅ Budget Check block present before small/large task split |
| plan.md Naming Rules | grep -c "Naming Rules" → 0 |
✅ TD-48 resolved |
| conventions.md §6 | view_file L150-160 |
✅ 4 rows + Rationale column |
| conventions.md §8 | grep config.md → L189 |
✅ config.md listed |
| conventions.md §15 | grep config.md → L283 |
✅ Role Lock entry |
| knowledge.md §Limits | view_file L107-118 |
✅ 4 rows, values match config |
| TS.md template L27 | view_file L27 |
✅ Inline defaults format |
| research.md L142-143 | view_file L142-143 |
✅ 2-line defaults header |
| config.md workflow | view_file full |
✅ Edit + Verify modes, Registry (3 categories, 16 entries) |
| glossary.md | grep "Config Sync Registry" → L152 |
✅ Term present |
| Adapter sync: config | diff config.md tfw-config.md → 0 |
✅ Byte-copy |
| Adapter sync: plan | diff plan.md tfw-plan.md → 0 |
✅ Byte-copy |
| Adapter sync: research | diff research.md tfw-research.md → 0 |
✅ Byte-copy |
| Adapter sync: knowledge | diff knowledge.md tfw-knowledge.md → 0 |
✅ Byte-copy |
| # | Source | Severity | File | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | RF obs. #1 | Low | .tfw/conventions.md |
§2 Required Artifacts doesn’t list config.md — only original 10 listed, but §8 now has 11 | ⬜ Backlog |
| 2 | RF obs. #2 | Low | .tfw/PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml |
tfw.workflows section missing config: .tfw/workflows/config.md |
⬜ Backlog |
| 3 | RF obs. #3 | Low | .tfw/conventions.md |
§10.1/10.2 numbering — pre-existing TD-45, still present | N/A (existing TD-45) |
| # | Category | Candidate | Source | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | convention | Pattern A (inline defaults + config key) is the standard for enforcement-critical values. Standard header: > Configured in... > Values below are defaults.... Pattern B (pure reference) proven to kill agent compliance |
HL-TFW-19, RES-TFW-19, RF-TFW-19 | High |
| 2 | process | Config Sync Registry pattern: config.md workflow maps YAML keys to file locations (section + row label). AI agent reads registry, finds sections, compares values. No scripts needed | config.md workflow | High |
| 3 | constraint | TS line numbers drift between writing and execution — always use content matching, not line-number targeting | RF obs., ONB §6 | Medium |
All 15 acceptance criteria met. Independent verification confirms:
Task addresses the root cause identified in the HL: Pattern B broke agent enforcement, Pattern A restores it with a systematic sync mechanism.
tfw-docs: Applied — KNOWLEDGE.md updated: +P11 (enforcement inline), +D24 (Pattern A + Config Sync Registry, supersedes D17), +config.md to Architecture Map, +TFW-19 key artifact, +2 legacy entries (Pattern B superseded, Naming Rules removed). TECH_DEBT.md: +TD-50, +TD-51 (added during REVIEW)
| *REVIEW — TFW-19: Config Propagation | 2026-04-03* |