trace-first-starter

RF — TFW-18: Knowledge Consolidation

Дата: 2026-04-03 Автор: Executor (AI) Статус: 🟢 RF — Выполнено Parent HL: HL-TFW-18 TS: TS TFW-18

---

1. Что сделано

Новые файлы

| Файл | Описание | |——|———-| | .tfw/workflows/knowledge.md | 4-phase consolidation workflow (Orient → Gather → Consolidate → Prune), ~100 lines | | .tfw/templates/TOPIC_FILE.md | Template for topic files in knowledge/ folder | | .tfw/knowledge_state.yaml | Initial knowledge tracking state with zeroed stats | | .agent/workflows/tfw-knowledge.md | Antigravity adapter for the new knowledge workflow |

Изменённые файлы

| Файл | Изменения | |——|———-| | .tfw/templates/RF.md | Added §6 Fact Candidates with quality filter + anti-patterns + categories | | .tfw/templates/REVIEW.md | Added §5 Fact Candidates with quality filter + anti-patterns + categories | | .tfw/templates/RES.md | Added Fact Candidates subsection in Closure (before Conclusion) | | .tfw/workflows/handoff.md | Added 💡 mindset reminder about Fact Candidates in RF writing step | | .tfw/workflows/research.md | Added 💡 mindset reminder about Fact Candidates before Closure Protocol | | .tfw/workflows/review.md | Added 💡 mindset reminder about Fact Candidates in REVIEW writing step | | .tfw/templates/KNOWLEDGE.md | Added §5 Project Facts compact index with category/count/link table | | .tfw/workflows/init.md | Added Step 5: .user_preferences.md template + .gitignore guidance | | .tfw/PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml | Added tfw.knowledge section (6 params) + knowledge in workflows list | | .tfw/workflows/docs.md | Added item 6 to checklist: Fact Candidates marker | | .tfw/conventions.md | Added Fact Candidates to §3, knowledge.md row to §8, §10.1 Fact Categories, §10.2 Knowledge Infrastructure | | .tfw/glossary.md | Added 4 terms: Fact Candidate, Topic File, Knowledge Gate, Consolidation | | .tfw/workflows/plan.md | Added Phase 0: Knowledge Gate Check before Phase 1 | | .agent/workflows/tfw-handoff.md | Synced from canonical | | .agent/workflows/tfw-research.md | Synced from canonical | | .agent/workflows/tfw-review.md | Synced from canonical | | .agent/workflows/tfw-docs.md | Synced from canonical | | .agent/workflows/tfw-plan.md | Synced from canonical |

2. Ключевые решения

1. REVIEW.md §5 placement: TS said “After §4 Verdict” but REVIEW template §4 is “Traces Updated”, §2 is “Verdict”. Added §5 FC after §4 (end of review), which is the logical position per HL intent.
2. Adapter sync: All 5 existing adapters are byte-identical copies of canonical workflows. Used cp to overwrite after modifying canonicals, ensuring exact sync.

3. Acceptance Criteria

• RF.md template has §6 Fact Candidates with quality filter and anti-patterns
• REVIEW.md template has §5 Fact Candidates with quality filter
• RES.md template has Fact Candidates in Closure section
• handoff.md, research.md, review.md each have 1 mindset reminder about Fact Candidates
• KNOWLEDGE.md template has §5 Project Facts compact index
• .tfw/workflows/knowledge.md exists with 4-phase process, role lock, behavior rules
• .tfw/templates/TOPIC_FILE.md exists
• .tfw/knowledge_state.yaml exists with initial state
• PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml has tfw.knowledge section with 6 configurable parameters
• tfw-docs checklist has item 6 (Fact Candidates marker)
• plan.md has Phase 0 Knowledge Gate Check
• conventions.md has Fact Candidates definition + categories + new files
• glossary.md has 4 new terms
• All 6 adapters synced (5 modified + 1 new)
• No changes to main pipeline diagrams
• Grep verification: “Fact Candidates” appears in RF.md, REVIEW.md, RES.md templates

4. Верификация

• Lint (echo "configure your lint command"): N/A (markdown files only)
• Tests (echo "configure your test command"): N/A (markdown files only)
• Verify: Grep verification passed — “Fact Candidates” found in all 3 templates, all 5 modified workflows, and all 6 adapter files. Phase 0 confirmed in both plan.md and adapter. 4 glossary terms confirmed. Knowledge config section confirmed with 6 parameters.

5. Observations (out-of-scope, not modified)

#	File	Line(s)	Type	Description
1	.tfw/conventions.md	170-196	naming	§10.1 and §10.2 numbering breaks the existing section numbering flow — §10 “Context Loading Order” follows immediately after §10.2. A future renumbering pass would fix this (§10/§11/§12 for the three new subsections, renumber old §10-§15 accordingly)
2	.tfw/workflows/init.md	100-113	style	Phase 5 verify checklist still references old numbering (Steps 5/6 → now Steps 6/7 after .user_preferences.md insertion). Tutorial text and anti-patterns unaffected
3	KNOWLEDGE.md (project)	120	todo	Live KNOWLEDGE.md doesn’t have §5 Project Facts yet — only the template does. Will be added during first /tfw-knowledge run or next /tfw-docs

6. Fact Candidates

Record what you learned about this project that would change how the NEXT agent approaches a similar task. If it wouldn’t change their decision — don’t record it.

Anti-patterns: “project uses git”, “code is in Python”, “tests exist” These are NOT verified facts. They become facts after /tfw-knowledge consolidation.

#	Category	Candidate	Source	Confidence
1	convention	Adapter files in .agent/workflows/ are exact byte-copies of .tfw/workflows/ — cp is the correct sync method, not manual editing	Verified during execution — file sizes match	High
2	convention	Some .tfw/ files use CRLF (KNOWLEDGE template, docs.md) while others use LF. No consistency rule exists	Observed during template editing	Medium
3	environment	.tfw/conventions.md section numbering is flat (§1-§15 at time of TFW-18) with no hierarchy — adding subsections (§10.1, §10.2) is a first and may need future normalization	conventions.md structure observation	Medium

Categories (open list): environment, process, stakeholder, constraint, convention, domain, context, risk

fact-candidates: processed 2026-04-03

---

*RF — TFW-18: Knowledge Consolidation

2026-04-03*

This site is open source. Improve this page.