Date: 2026-03-30 Author: Coordinator (AI) Verdict: ✅ APPROVE RF: RF Phase B TS: TS Phase B
| # | Check | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DoD met? (all TS acceptance criteria) | ✅ | All 7 criteria verified: Phase 3.5 gate, 4 pipeline diagrams, artifact table, conventions §2+§8, glossary (4 items). Grep confirms 0 stale “three canonical” in .tfw/. |
| 2 | Code quality (conventions, naming, type hints) | ✅ | Markdown formatting consistent with existing styles. Phase 3.5 numbering avoids renumbering existing steps — pragmatic choice. |
| 3 | Test coverage (tests written and passing) | ✅ | N/A for Markdown. Pipeline grep (TODO.*HL.*TS) verified all live files show 🔬 RES. Historical task artifacts correctly retain old pipeline. |
| 4 | Philosophy aligned (matches HL design philosophy) | ✅ | RESEARCH gate follows recommend/ask/never-skip logic from HL. Skip path preserved. “RES optional” consistently noted. |
| 5 | Tech debt (shortcuts documented?) | ✅ | No shortcuts. Two ONB recommendations adopted (Evolution section counts, Canonical Workflows table) — both within same file scope, documented in RF Key Decisions. |
| 6 | Security (no secrets exposed, guards in place) | N/A | Markdown only |
| 7 | Breaking changes (backward compat, migrations) | ✅ | Additive only. Phase 3.5 inserted without renumbering. Skip path preserves old HL→TS flow. |
| 8 | Style & standards (code style, conventions) | ✅ | English throughout. Tables, pipeline diagrams, status emoji consistent across all 6 files. |
| 9 | Observations collected (executor reported findings) | ✅ | 5 observations — all adapter/init desyncs outside TS scope. Properly categorized as desync type. |
✅ APPROVE
Phase B resolves all 8 Tech Debt items from Phase A REVIEW (#1-8) and adds the RESEARCH gate to plan.md. All 6 files modified as specified. Pipeline diagrams are now consistent across all live framework files. The 5 new observations are residual adapter/init desyncs appropriate for Phase C.
| # | Source | Severity | File | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | RF Obs #1 | Low | .agent/workflows/tfw-plan.md:131 |
Antigravity adapter copy of plan.md still shows old pipeline (no 🔬 RES) | → Phase C |
| 2 | RF Obs #2 | Low | .tfw/init.md:30-37 |
Step 2 PROJECT_CONFIG.yaml example doesn’t include res template |
→ Phase C |
| 3 | RF Obs #3 | Low | .tfw/init.md:87-93 |
Antigravity workflow copy commands missing research.md |
→ Phase C |
| 4 | RF Obs #4 | Low | .tfw/README.md:73 |
Project Structure tree comment missing RES in templates list | → Phase C |
| 5 | RF Obs #5 | Low | .tfw/README.md:74 |
Project Structure tree comment missing research in workflows list | → Phase C |
| *REVIEW — TFW-11 / Phase B: Integration — Plan Gate + Pipeline Desyncs | 2026-03-30* |